THE FUTURE OF NEW MEXICO SCOREBOARD | HEALTHCARE

New Mexico Healthcare Scoreboard

Access to affordable, timely care affects life expectancy, family stability and New Mexico’s ability to attract workers.

Overall status Losing

Updated October 2026

  • Winning
  • Losing
  • Context

Regional comparison: Arizona, Colorado, Oklahoma, Texas and Utah.

New Mexico trails the regional or national benchmark on nine of 12 scored measures.

  • 3 Winning
  • 9 Losing

SECTION 1

ACCESS & COVERAGE

1

Adults with a personal doctor or health care provider (% of adults 18+)

Losing

Do you have a doctor who knows your name? Nearly three in 10 New Mexico adults don't — the worst gap on this page, and the number that best captures the 'can't get in anywhere' complaint.

Source CDC BRFSS, 2024 (BRFSS)

2

ER wait: median time in the emergency department (discharged patients)

Losing

Duration from walking into an ER to walking out: about 2 hours, 43 minutes in New Mexico — 22 minutes longer than the norm for neighboring states. Wait times everywhere are measured straight off hospital clocks. Besides frustration and boredom, lengthy wait times can cause severe patient harm, lead to higher overall health care costs, and result in systemic strain across a state's entire medical infrastructure.

Source CMS Care Compare, Oct 2024 - Sep 2025 (CMS OP-18b reporting period)

3

ER walk-outs: patients who left before being seen (%)

Losing

The number of patients who gave up and left the ER before a doctor ever saw them is about one in 33 here, roughly double the norm of surrounding states. That people would rather give up than wait is perhaps the clearest signal that waits are too long.

Source CMS Care Compare, Jan-Dec 2024 (CMS OP-22 reporting period)

4

Share of residents living in a primary-care shortage area (% of population)

Losing

Nearly half the state lives in an area the federal government has flagged as short on primary care. That compares to fewer than a third for states around us. This story is primarily one of rural New Mexico - with residents facing delayed care and worsened patient outcomes - but it places a strain on health care systems statewide, impacting everyone.

Source HRSA via KFF, HPSA population as of Dec. 31, 2025; state population 2024 ACS

5

Residents with private health insurance (% of population)

Losing

Regarding insurance you get through a job or buy yourself — as opposed to a government program or nothing - barely one in three New Mexicans has it, versus over half in neighboring states. Utah is the exception with seven in 10 having it. This is the job market and the health care system telling the same story: The state runs on public coverage because private-sector paychecks with benefits are scarce.

Source KFF (Census ACS), 2024 (ACS via KFF)

6

Medicaid share of population (% of population)

Context

One in three New Mexicans gets health coverage through Medicaid — double the norm of surrounding states. With this safety net doing such heavy lifting here, it exposes our state budget to any change from Washington. (Context, not scored — high enrollment is neither simply good nor bad.)

Source KFF (Census ACS), 2024 (ACS 1-year)

SECTION 2

HEALTH OUTCOMES

7

Life expectancy at birth (years)

Losing

How long can a baby born here expect to live?: 74.5 years, about two and a half years less than the surrounding state average. This metric is perhaps the single bluntest summary of a state's health.

Source CDC / NCHS, 2022

8

Premature death (years of potential life lost)

Losing

This metric weighs a 25-year-old's death far heavier than a 75-year-old's. New Mexico loses about 40% more early-life years to deaths before age 75 than the area norm, driven by overdoses, crashes and violence. A high premature death rate indicates systemic public health challenges, socioeconomic disparities, and limited access to quality healthcare.

Source America's Health Rankings (CDC data), 2023

SECTION 3

PROVIDER SUPPLY

9

Primary care clinicians incl. nurse practitioners and PAs (providers per 100,000 population)

Winning

Everyone on the front line of primary care — doctors, nurse practitioners and physician assistants — is included here. Our number, 297 for every 100,000, is high partly because New Mexico relies more on NPs and PAs than most states. That number also does not reflect how many of those providers will accept new patients.

Source CMS NPPES via America's Health Rankings, September 2025 (NPPES)

10

Primary care doctors only (MDs and DOs)

Winning

Considering doctors only, New Mexico still leads our comparative states per capita (168 per 100K vs 141), though it trails the nation. So the 'can't get in anywhere' problem is real, but its cause lives in the other rows — doctors near retirement, clustered in the metros, closed panels, and the fact that half the state is in a shortage zone.

Source KFF (Redi-Data physician counts), Physician counts May 2026 (KFF/Redi-Data); population 2024 (KFF/ACS)

11

Mental health providers per 100,000 people

Winning

Counselors, therapists, psychologists and psychiatric providers - New Mexico's supply is the strongest in the region. Getting an appointment in rural counties is the catch.

Source CMS NPPES via America's Health Rankings, September 2025 (NPPES)

SECTION 4

MALPRACTICE & PRACTICE ENVIRONMENT

12

OB/GYN malpractice insurance premium (independent practice)

Losing

What does an independent OB/GYN pay for one year of malpractice insurance in New Mexico: about $102,000 — nearly double the neighbors' average. For a small practice, that's a salary gone before the first baby is delivered.

Source FL OIR via nmlegis handout, 2024

13

What NM doctors pay for malpractice coverage vs. neighboring states (OSI actuarial comparison)

Context

Averaged across specialties, New Mexico doctors pay roughly twice what colleagues pay next door — and that comparison comes from the state insurance regulator's own actuary, not an advocacy group. (Context — regulator's comparison, not a full 50-state table.)

Source NM OSI / nmlegis, 2025 (presented Nov 6, 2025)

14

Malpractice payouts vs. premiums (insurer loss ratio)

Losing

The engine behind the premium pain?: For every $1 that malpractice insurers collected in New Mexico in 2024, they paid out about $1.39 in claims and defense costs. That ranks us as the 2nd worst state in America, and worst the year before. Every neighboring state was comfortably profitable for insurers (49-76 cents on the dollar). When payouts beat premiums two years running, rate hikes and insurer exits follow. Straight from insurers' own regulatory filings.

Source FL OIR (NAIC filings), 2024 (FL OIR annual report, Oct 1, 2025, from NAIC filings)